Blog Layout

Deck Remodeling vs. New Deck Construction; Which is the Best Choice?

Sam NyBlom • April 14, 2021

Content updated July 7, 2023


Are you contemplating remodeling your existing deck or starting fresh with a brand-new one? Making this decision requires careful consideration of various factors. At Precision Homecrafters, we understand the dilemma homeowners face regarding deck projects. Let us shed light on the pros and cons of remodeling versus starting over, helping you make an informed choice.


Remodeling an existing deck can seem appealing, but critical aspects must be considered. Here's an anecdote from one of our projects that highlights the importance of a solid foundation in deck construction:


We recently encountered a deck remodeling project where clients wanted us to freshen up their deck by replacing the decking boards alone. However, upon inspecting the support posts, we noticed significant concerns. We recognized the need for a sturdy foundation, so we advised tearing down the existing structure and starting anew. The clients were initially hesitant due to the perceived additional work and expenses, but we explained the reasoning behind our recommendation.


When evaluating whether to remodel or start over, keep the following points in mind:


Structural Integrity 


Existing decks may have support posts buried underground or set in concrete prone to moisture exposure, fungal growth, and decay. Starting over allows you to address these issues by building a solid foundation from the ground up.


Design Flexibility


Starting fresh opens up a world of design possibilities. You can create a deck that perfectly matches your vision, incorporating
the latest trends, materials, and features.


Safety and Compliance


Building codes and regulations continually evolve to ensure the
safety of deck structures. Starting over allows you to meet or exceed the latest standards, providing peace of mind and avoiding costly issues during inspections or resale.


Long-Term Durability


Remodeled decks may still have underlying issues that could resurface in the future. Starting over enables you to construct a deck with superior materials, such as double-treated bands and joists, ensuring longevity and minimizing maintenance needs.

At Precision Homecrafters, we emphasize a comprehensive approach to deck construction. Our process involves: 


  • Transparent Communication: Our experienced team provides honest feedback and expert recommendations based on your deck's specific needs and desired outcomes.
  • Customized Solutions: Whether remodeling or starting over, we tailor our services to meet your preferences, budget, and timeline, ensuring a deck that exceeds your expectations.
  • Quality Craftsmanship: Our skilled professionals employ top-notch materials, modern construction techniques, and meticulous attention to detail to deliver a deck that stands the test of time.


When considering deck remodeling, it's essential to think beyond surface-level improvements. You can make an informed decision by evaluating the condition of your support posts, the integrity of the existing structure, and the long-term goals for your deck. 


Remember, a deck built on a solid foundation guarantees aesthetic appeal, safety, durability, and lasting enjoyment for years to come.
Contact us today for a consultation.

You might also like

Home Renovation Project Expectations
By Sam NyBlom October 12, 2023
Navigate your home renovation project with ease! Learn what to expect, from construction challenges to celebrating milestones, with Precision Homecrafters.
By Sam NyBlom April 14, 2021
Updated Jun 5, 2023 Are you considering a house renovation but need help figuring out where to begin? Don't worry; you're not alone. Renovating a house can be daunting, especially if you need help figuring out where to start. As remodeling specialists, Precision Homecrafters understands the challenges homeowners face during this process. This blog post will provide expert advice on where to start when renovating a house into your dream home. Engage Professional Remodeling Services Working with a professional remodeling team is crucial to ensure a successful renovation. Precision Homecrafters has extensive experience in delivering reliable and professional remodeling services. They can guide you through every step, from design conceptualization to project completion. Their expertise and attention to detail will help bring your vision to life while ensuring quality craftsmanship. Define Your Goals The first step in any successful renovation project is to define your goals. Take time to envision what you want to achieve with your renovation. Are you looking to create more functional living spaces, enhance aesthetics, or increase the value of your home? Precision Homecrafters' experts can help guide you through numerous questions to consider–from budget creation to planning and execution. Clearly understanding your goals will help you prioritize and plan accordingly. Assess Your Budget Before diving into the renovation process, assessing your budget is essential. Determine how much you will invest in the project and allocate funds for different aspects, such as materials, labor, permits, and contingencies. Consulting with a remodeling specialist like Precision Homecrafters can help you understand the costs and make informed decisions. For instance, will your budget allow all of the work to be done simultaneously, or will it need to be done in phases? Performing all of the work at once typically results in cost savings. Conduct a Home Inspection To identify any underlying issues and plan for necessary repairs, it's crucial to conduct a thorough home inspection. Hire a professional inspector who can assess the condition of your home's structure, electrical systems, plumbing, and HVAC. This evaluation will help you address any hidden problems before commencing renovations. Research and Plan Is this your forever home, or do you plan to move in five years or less? Significant investments into your home that utilize higher quality materials and workmanship seldom yield a 100% return in the short term. These investments are generally made to improve the overall quality of life and day-to-day functionality, and the return on investment is realized over a more extended period of time. Profit on short-term fix-ups frequently includes superficial upgrades, builder-grade materials, and mediocre workmanship—research design ideas , materials, and finishes that align with your vision. Create a detailed plan outlining the changes you want to make in each area of your home. This plan will serve as a roadmap throughout the renovation process. Obtain Necessary Permits Depending on the scope of your renovation, you may need to obtain permits from your local municipality. Precision Homecrafters can assist you in navigating the permitting process, ensuring that your renovation adheres to building codes and regulations. Obtaining the necessary permits is essential to avoid potential legal issues and ensure the safety and compliance of your project. Starting a house renovation project can be overwhelming, but with careful planning and guidance from remodeling experts like Precision Homecrafters, you can turn your vision into a reality. Begin by defining your goals, assessing your budget, conducting a thorough home inspection, and prioritizing key areas. Research and plan diligently, engage professional remodeling services, and obtain the necessary permits. With Precision Homecrafters by your side, you can confidently embark on your renovation journey and transform your house into your dream home. Contact us today.
Building the Ultimate Man Cave
By Sam NyBlom April 14, 2021
Discover how to transform your basement into the ultimate man cave with our comprehensive guide to building a man cave.
More Posts
Share by: